Lessons from the 1940s – Discretion
US poster, World War II
During World War II, posters like these decorated storefronts, train stations, and other public places. Spies were present. An innocent conversation in the barber shop, the grocery, or a phone booth could be overheard and passed to the enemy. Information about troop movements, sailing schedules, and strength of the armed forces was especially guarded. One careless comment could lead to thousands of deaths.
Free speech is one of the cornerstones of American society, but during the war, limits were accepted in order to protect lives – and ultimately those very freedoms. Citizens understood that free speech without discretion could be harmful.
Lives may no longer be on the line, but a lack of discretion causes a new realm of problems unimagined seventy years ago. The speed of Twittering, Facebook, and blogging, coupled with the popularity of full self-expression, can lead to great hurt and damage. In the past year, I have seen on-line…
- Spouses trashing mates or ex-mates.
- Employees griping about jobs and bosses – on work time.
- Parents posting pictures from Disneyland – when they called the children in sick from school.
- Comments about hangovers and getting wasted.
- Students sniping about teachers by name.
- Unpublished writers lamenting the drivel on the bookshelves – published by houses they’d like to write for.
- People requesting prayer on very personal matters for other people.
- Citizens wishing harm or failure to politicians or celebrities.
US poster, 1943
Perhaps a return to self-censorship is warranted. Before hitting “share,” if we all took a few seconds to consider the possible impact of our posts, a lot of damage could be prevented. I run through a mental checklist – would I want these people reading this post – my husband, parents, children, boss, pastor, neighbor…and the person I’m writing about (even celebrities have feelings)? I have failed. I’ve posted things I regretted and removed. But if we all tried, civility could replace anger on the Internet.
Loose lips may no longer sink ships, but they can sink families, reputations, and careers. Thoughts?
Well I don’t mind doing #6, sometimes it just bugs me. I’m not gonna post a rant on here, after all I have respect for your blog. And I’m not ashamed of doing #6 either. Cause the houses that publish things I don’t like I don’t want to be published there either. I’m even debating being published in the Christian market all together.
Very good post. I marvel at this ‘too much information’ age that we live in. Is it a lack of discretion, self discipline, or common sense, or all of the above? Reminds me of the many scriptures in Proverbs that talk about our speech and whatnot.
It’s always good to self monitor when posting on these sites. I agree that a lot of damage can be done for no good reason.
We all have a responsibility to our readers.
Good post.